First published in Tech Policy Press, 11/13/26
See live Supplement for notes and ongoing updates.
Comments are invited -- via the Substack version of this article.
Subscribe to my Substack (free) to receive new posts.
Part I: Foundational framings and collective action for pro-human AI as it absorbs social media
The recent US
midterm elections delivered a mandate
to change course on AI. Voters elected new leaders for federal and state
offices that they believe will favor people over Big Tech and take a more
muscular approach to regulating AI and data centers. The popular demand for
intervention is now unmistakable. But what kind of intervention is necessary?
New alliances are popping up to try to answer that question.
For instance, a new “Pro-Human
AI Coalition” of more than 60 organizations launched just weeks before the
midterms. It joins much good
work already underway to return technology toward the path of augmentation
— using technology to make people more capable, rather than replacing them.
But first in social media and now in AI, those efforts have
mostly been siloed,
fragmented, little-recognized, and under-resourced. I have been arguing
for an alliance like this for some time, after seeking technology that augments human
intellect rather than replacing it since 1969.
Now there is new hope for realignment, spurred by widespread
fear that we are at a tipping point. For those who want technology to be
pro-human, it is time to treat the new problems of AI and the still unresolved
problems of social media as related parts of the same challenge: building a
digital ecosystem that serves people and democracy, not corporate platforms.
This is one of the great challenges of our age. Over the
past decade of social media, as it became clear that the technology was weakening
human thinking and collective decision-making rather than augmenting it, many
have come to understand that this is not just a technology problem, but a
broader sociotechnical
one. There are many technical and nontechnical levers to reverse it, but no
silver bullet. I see three overarching disconnects that a coalition could help
fix — and offer a few simple framing principles to address them.
Thanks for reading Smartly Intertwingled! Subscribe for free
to receive new posts.
Disconnect 1: AI and social media are merging
The first disconnect is that AI is not separate from social
media, but is fusing with and absorbing it. The so-called “AI” and “social
media” fields must
work together to build an
ecosystem that serves people. AI already shapes what we see on social
media, it is starting to take over some of social media’s role in filtering
information, and it draws on social media content (which is very uneven in
quality) for training. So far, the hyperscaling of AI has largely overlooked
the fact that humans evolved and flourished as social creatures — and
to the related lessons of social media’s failure to serve real human
connection and institutions.
At the same time, the platforms we call “social media” are becoming
increasingly less social, suggesting a need to face a new reality of “post-social media” or “parasocial
media.”
But can humanity survive and flourish in a “post-social”
world of people talking to computers, rather than one of people talking to
people, augmented by computers? To channel RFK Sr., who borrowed from George
Bernard Shaw, media scholars must help us see things as they are, and ask why,
and media architects must dream of things that can be better and ask, why not?
For AI to become pro-human it must be not only pro-individual but
also pro-community — it must help people connect with each other. Think
of this as “AI/SM” (AI and social media as one), or as “intelligent,
pro-social media” (using “media” in McLuhan’s
broad sense).
I hope the Pro-Human AI Coalition will also address the
inseparable cause of pro-social media. That would seem consistent with the April
report from Project Liberty (a founder of the coalition) and the Social Web
Foundation (PL-SWF), which makes a clear case for that holistic focus,
surveying key issues raised as AI and social media merge. Whatever one’s
assessment of existential
risk, societal
risk is already a clear and present danger common to both AI and social
media.
Disconnect 2: Tech is ignoring our social nature
The second disconnect is that neither mainstream AI nor
social media are being built to support the rich social dynamics essential to
humanity — the nuanced interplay between individuals and the dense network of
communities and institutions that has co-evolved over millennia. Some scholars
propose addressing this by combining siloed technologies that can reinforce
each other (notably “AI and the
future of digital public squares,” by Beth Goldberg and 26 coauthors; “Prosocial Media,” by Glen Weyl
and others; and “Improving social
media for democratic discourse,” by Fan Cheng and others). Some civil
society organizations take a similarly broad view, again notably including the
PL-SWF report.
Disconnect 3: Remediation requires a whole-of-society
project
A third disconnect is that even as these ideas gain
recognition, putting fixes into practice is difficult. There are an
overwhelming number of them, the devil is in the many details, and
broad-spectrum reform is a complex sociotechnical process gated at human speed.
I have previously proposed
a broad, pro-human AI and social media coalition to close these disconnects: “a
loosely federated, ‘big-tent’ alliance for a portfolio approach to motivate and
guide the ongoing whole-of-society project needed to evolve a healthy
sociotechnical ecosystem.” The newly formed Pro-Human AI Coalition promises to
be the start of that — and can help guide a new awakening in US policy.
My suggested high-level architecture includes emerging
support tools for social mediation processes (how others help us filter and
make sense of information), individual and community control of attention,
community representation, and a relentless focus on whose interests AI serves.
This architecture offers a positive vision that goes beyond fixing problems. It
would empower people and the collective intelligence of their many overlapping
communities to select, govern, build, interconnect, and evolve the agents and
services that shape how we think together, so that they serve everyone.
This Part 1 provides an overview of a few guiding
principles. Part 2 expands on how they function to support pro-human objectives
and then concludes with a call for a “big tent” alliance to obtain agreement on
— and guide ongoing development toward — those shared principles. A supplement provides additional notes,
references, and updates.
Focusing on a few big-tent framing principles
These are wicked problems with no simple solution. They are
far too complex, nuanced, and context-dependent for any one person or group to
fully understand. Additionally, progress has been slow because dominant
platforms’ business models and centralized designs underweight the public good
and user rights, while policy responses have remained limited. What can shape
and hold a diverse portfolio of efforts together is a small set of shared
principles that work at different levels: thought
as a social process, three
pillars of healthy discourse, negotiated
access to user attention and data, loyal personal
(and community) AI agents and a simple, essential and overarching question:
who
does it serve? These principles are aligned with the more detailed Pro-Human AI Declaration, but meant to
be simpler and more universally compelling.
Principle 1: Thought as a social process
![]() |
| —Richard Reisman |
Debates rage over expression as a matter of “free speech
rights” in isolation, often on a “for me but not for thee” basis. But the real
issue is the breakdown of this
broader process of how social creatures think. Online media harms are
commonly viewed as expression management problems, but it is managing attention
where we have lost our way. Attention had been organically manageable because
social influences helped guide it. Now, faced with more content creation than
anyone can process, we
need feed algorithms, or “attention agents,” to help us. Platforms have
taken over that role, but their algorithms fail to guide attention in the
nuanced way human social mediation once did.
Historically, word of mouth and other forms of social
mediation naturally helped us self-regulate both expression and attention. But
now platforms control feeds and reputation signals such as likes and shares.
Their engagement-optimized systems redirect our social feedback systems toward
maximizing engagement, which often diverges from what users and communities
need, while marginalizing important components of our social mediation
ecosystem.
Principle 2: The three pillars of online discourse,
linked by open interoperability
The
coalition calls for “Designing a Pro-Human Al Stack…Building architecture
for Al systems that are safe, open, and fair.” I suggest the Three
Pillars illustrated in Figure 2 as important, mutually reinforcing aspects
of that stack. They show how healthy discourse works: individual and social
processes that guide each other, plus the reputation that emerges from and
feeds back into them.
Pillars of discourse
![]() |
| —Richard Reisman |
The first pillar is about individual choice and agency: the primal human process that steers our inputs through our attention, drives individual thought, and outputs expressed ideas to the network. The second is the social mediation ecosystem: the deliberative (or reactive) feedback processes by which others, both human and machine, mediate message contexts and flows from speakers to listeners, much as in the earliest word-of-mouth propagation. The third is reputation and trust: distillations from the other pillars, which feed back to them, evaluating whether speakers and mediators’ context are worthy of attention (relevant, valid, and desired).
All three pillars are essential, because each one has
weaknesses the others can balance. Individual choice and agency is the focus of
much reform effort, but there are valid
concerns that, if poorly-mediated, it can lead to echo-chambers,
polarization, and extremism. Social mediation is how society has always
“moderated” (not eliminated) individual excesses, but without sufficient
individual agency, it can drive groupthink and tyranny of the majority.
Reputation and trust connects the two pillars in a feedback loop, distilling
what people choose, share, and comment on into a kind of socially-derived
metadata that guides further attention and interaction.
Open
interoperability, which enables what is often called middleware (software that sits
between users and platforms), is the foundation for that interplay. As
code increasingly shapes discourse and cultural
evolution, interoperability must be built in to preserve the agency,
flexibility, extensibility, and resilience that humans and our social systems
historically developed more organically. Monolithic, centralized walled gardens
are too rigid for that, no matter how benevolently intended.
Beneath this foundation sit the networking platforms
themselves, along with a layer of technical foundations such as alignment,
integrity, transparency, privacy and security, resourcing foundations
such as revenue
and incentives models, and civic foundations such as regulation,
standards, and civics education — all of which are important to being
pro-human.
Principle 3: Negotiated access to user attention and data
Much of the harm of online media and the failure to
seriously address it arguably stems from the extractive ad-based revenue models
that dominate current social media — and may soon dominate consumer AI
services. The Internet’s “original
sin” is not advertising itself, but abusively extracting user attention and
data with little or no user control — or compensation. Alternative funding
models are also desirable, but reforming the ad model, which currently
incentivizes harmful engagement over quality might be one of most expeditious
solutions. We should aggressively pursue both.
Users should control the terms
by which others can access their attention and personal data, including preferences
and intentions. Advertising
can be of value when it is relevant to a user and not abusive of their
attention or privacy. “Reverse
metering” can credit users for the value (attention, data, content, and
other) they provide to platforms and advertisers, offsetting any user fees.
Negotiating the exchange on that basis might make it fairer, rewarding users
commensurate with whatever level of attention and data they share — and make
advertising more valuable to both consumers and advertisers.
Principle 4: Personal AIs delegated as faithfully loyal
advocate agents
AI compounds the new sociotechnical problems that social
media has produced but failed to solve. Providers of AI models exert similar,
but far deeper and more subtle influence over what we see of the world and how
we make sense of it. In addition to making parallel concerns of bias,
manipulation, and misinformation less tractable to independent oversight, the
seductive power of AI can threaten human attachment
and lead from simple cognitive outsourcing toward cognitive
surrender. As we move toward hybrids of human and AI intelligence, we face
the same question: do our technology-based agents serve us, or the corporations
that build and deploy them?
As we move from monolithic AIs to complexes of AI agents,
the same pillars and need for open interoperability apply. For individual
choice and agency: do we each decide what objectives are set and what
sources are used? For social mediation: do we make full use of the
wisdom of other individual humans “in the loop” and of the communities we
choose? For reputation and trust: do we draw wisely on other humans and
hybrids with transparency into who and what we are relying on?
AI developers have made much of the idea of growing agent capability,
but not of AI relationship: OpenAI drew attention to capability as “agenticness,”
the ability of an AI system to do things on its own. Richard Whitt and others
emphasize a second dimension, which Whitt calls “agentiality:”
an AI’s relationship to those it serves and whether it can be trusted to
loyally serve them.
Given the complexity and dynamics of AI, our surest
protection as individuals and communities is to be able to say “Have
your AI call my AI.” That means selecting and delegating personal
AI agents (PAIs) that we can trust to represent us as faithfully loyal
advocates — sometimes even fiduciaries with
legal duty to serve our interests, not those of their providers or any other
party. Technology for ensuring trustworthiness is still at an early stage, but
it is in active development.
Principle 5: The essential test question is “Who does it
serve?”
Instead of reacting to the harms of misaligned technology,
we should be building this brave new digital world to support fundamental and
broadly supported goals. Many raise concerns about whose interests AI
innovation is primarily serving. I suggest generalizing this into the single,
simplest, most essential principle to keep top-of-mind as we design, develop,
deploy, and use these new tools:
The essential test question at every decision point, for
every component, is “Who
does it serve?” This questions must be followed by two critical
sub-questions: the normative “Who should it serve?” and the
sociotechnical “Did we make sure it serves who it should serve?” All
else is commentary.
We must make media tools intelligently social
We must look to the forest we
want to live in, not just today’s nearby trees. Where do we want online
tech to go? Our objective must be to make our media tools intelligently
social — to fully support democratic
freedoms and the flourishing of humans as individual-but-social creatures
that cooperate in a full range of relationships, at multiple levels and in
multiple domains.
To achieve that objective, we need a sociotechnical
infrastructure that is broad-based, continuously evolving, open to diverse
experimentation at a range of scales, extensible, resilient, and governed to
serve each and all. The Pro-Human AI Coalition is well placed to catalyze that
“big tent” effort, across both AI and social media.
We are re-engineering and digitizing — at unprecedented
speed — social processes that humans have evolved over millennia. Humans and
the AI systems that serve them will need 1) a sense of direction and 2) time to
adapt to each other, shaping the tools as they shape us. In Part 2, I explore
the roots and tools of each pillar, and how a loose, big-tent alliance can take
the long view toward guiding and building that ecosystem as an ongoing,
whole-of-society project.
Part II: Understanding the framing principles and the call for collective action
Part 1 proposed five normative and architectural framing
principles for a broad portfolio response to the risks and opportunities that
AI and social media present to the public square, democracy, and human
flourishing. Part 2 explores the historical foundation of this architecture and
its continuing development, and it calls for a broad alliance to advance this
momentous — and fraught — sociotechnical project for humanity’s future.
The once and future process of our social mediation
ecosystems
Human intelligence and sense-making depend heavily on our
ability to communicate, cooperate, and learn from one another. Yet mainstream
AI development often neglects this social substrate — as well as the related,
and still poorly addressed, lessons of social media’s harm to the public
square and democracy.
Simplistic coding of social media, and now AI, lead to context
collapse — losing the social context of epistemic
dependence, norms, and values. Instead, digital augmentation needs
compensatory attention to social context support. Meanwhile, current AI
models collapse context even
more.
Anticipation of AI agents has triggered promising research
suggesting that, as agents interact with each other and with humans, they, too,
will need the kinds of social institutions that human cooperation has always
relied on. One study characterizes this as “the equilibrium-selection process through
which multiple actors navigate their interdependence.” Another maps multiple
levels of social mediation, across a range of scales and epochs, for “Existing Human Institutions”
and for “AGI Institutions.” A
thought-provoking analysis adapts to AI agents the way that human
agents constitute democracy. One group of AI researchers offers a
particularly evocative title: “Societal
and technological progress as sewing an ever-growing, ever-changing, patchy,
and polychrome quilt. Similar points had been raised from the social media
perspective (with limited impact), such as Mediating Consent
and Algorithmic
Displacement of Social Trust.
This human process of collective sense-making, decisions,
and action goes back to cavemen around campfires,
refined through ancient Greece and the Enlightenment philosophers. The Founders
baked this into American democracy, de
Tocqueville observed how informal associations are vital workshops for
democracy (1835-40), and Elinor
Ostrom highlighted the collaborative wisdom of community institutions for
governing the commons.
But now tech platforms are weakening the associations,
communities, and civil society institutions that effective democracy depends
on. This erosion began with mass media, as observed in Robert Putnam’s Bowling
Alone. Social media, in turn, distorts the public square and offers
no more than minimal support for community-centered interaction and
governance. AI is deepening this failing, as “cognitive
outsourcing” leads to “cognitive
surrender” and “relationslipping,”
and the “engagement economy” is driving deeper into our social being, creating
a pseudo-social “attachment
economy.”
The movement to decentralize social media is a powerful, but
oversimplified, pendulum-swing reaction to this problem. The solution is a more
nuanced recognition that society is built on dense
multidimensional networks of communities and institutions that are semi-permeably
connected — not just isolated, insular groups. Deeper openness in protocols
and multi-agent interop enable vital architectural flexibility for rebuilding
this equilibrium-selection process of democracy — human to human, AI to AI, and
human to AI.
Social-media alternatives already demonstrate an increasing
range of grassroots redevelopment through open protocols. Bluesky’s AT Protocol, for
instance, now supports a wider “ATmosphere”
of independent services, with Blacksky
as an early example, and Eurosky and Gander emerging. Similar openness in AI
could enable rich community-centered services and user-selected,
community-curated attention agents.
Primacy of the agency pillar
Agency is the primal pillar of healthy discourse — necessary
but not sufficient on its own. Unlike other social animals, we are defined by
our human rights as individuals. We can delegate our agency to communities,
tools, and agents (human or AI), but retain primacy.
Democracy’s central tension is between the interests of
individuals and those of communities. Again, choice is essential to “cooperation: the equilibrium-selection
process through which multiple actors navigate their interdependence” —
even without any fixed hierarchy or other structure — and not an optimization
problem with a “solution” to be imposed as
some suppose.
Many fear excesses
of agency, and some are unavoidable. But robust social mediation ecosystems
and reputation systems nudge people toward responsibility and discernment. To
live and thrive in any degree of harmony with the norms and values of society,
one needs to maintain a good reputation. Done well, organic mediation enabled
freedom of expression to flourish with little need for censorship (“moderation
as removal”).
Open protocols are already becoming an alternative to
reliance on monolithic social media platforms, enabling services that are more
supportive of agency. The multiple platforms that make up the Fediverse
and the newer, more flexible Bluesky
ATmosphere
ecosystem demonstrate growing demand for portability, open interoperability,
and user control.
In AI, too, there is growing recognition that agency in
choice and control is vital to make AI work in diverse domains and contexts,
enabled by many dimensions of
openness in models and sourcing. The challenges of effective cooperation of
agents with humans and with each other has triggered a flurry of research on
collaborative structures that has potential to reinvigorate both human
democracy and how AI serves us. These challenges also add whole
new dimensions to the principal-agent problem.
Tools for agency
The agency pillar has had the broadest influence in the tech
and policy community, with much activity during the dot-com era, and now a
resurgence in reaction to platform overreach and disruption. Recent
social-media directions emphasize user-selectable feed algorithms and
middleware, along with more control over personal data — but AI development is
only just beginning to explore its equivalents, such as personal AI advocate
agents. Legal mandates for relevant rights of delegation
and fiduciary
responsibilities, and for interoperation
and portability, remain unsettled.
There is also growing recognition that monolithic AI models
are unreliable (and opaque) about the sources they draw on, which makes
user-controlled sourcing essential to quality results. Many businesses are
building domain-specific AI models, but a more general solution may be in
models that are designed for Attribution-Based
Control (ABC). This is very analogous to the source selectivity in social
media feed algorithms that social media middleware seeks to enable.
Social mediation: tools for communities as first-class
institutional principals
Communities need tools that serve them as institutions, with
agency of their own — not merely as sets of users. Social mediation may be the
least recognized and understood pillar of healthy “AI/SM” (AI and social media
as one), even as much current prosocial work is rediscovering it. Goldberg
and her 26 co-authors make a compelling case for developing together the
related families of technology that support social mediation: deliberation,
bridging and community-driven moderation, with proof of humanity as a
foundation for all three.
Goldberg et al. present a compelling call to better serve
communities, including by public-centered design, multilevel governance, and
bespoke tooling, with support from civil society, academia, and the public
sector complementing industry.
I suggest taking empowerment further: to give individuals
and communities structural power to choose, substitute, govern, and federate
systems and agents. This is where agency and social mediation intersect.
Because this technology is mission-critical, specialized, and context-specific,
communities should draw on the long-established example of “enterprise
IT” to be able to select and customize their own tools and loyal advocate
agents from an open market, rather than depend on a general-purpose platform
provider.
Communities need tech tools that their leaders, staff, and
agents (human, AI, and hybrid), can use and manage to work with their members.
Examples include member relationship, content management, community governance,
federation, and inter-community negotiation systems. They may come from a mix
of for-profit, non-profit, and public suppliers. This requires a supporting
ecosystem of “Independent Software Vendors (ISVs)”, system integration services
(across families and pillars and operational support), modularity, open tech
stack support for a full spectrum of institutional formality, size, and scope,
and inter-community services for managing graduated degrees of
permeability (and safety).
Digitizing systems support for the reputation/trust
pillar
Reputation and trust online need far more systematic support
than the word of mouth they have traditionally relied on. Goldberg et al.
address proof of humanity as a “foundational need” that applies across the
other three technology families as increasingly critical infrastructure for
online interactions and recognizes a spectrum of hybrids. The authors also
discuss reputation systems as relevant to community-driven moderation.
I generalize and distinguish reputation as a third broad
trust pillar, including proof of humanity and much more, that is dynamically
derived from, and feeds back into, the processes of the other two pillars.
Traditionally, reputation and trust were intuitive and
informal, drawing primarily on word of mouth. In some domains they grew into
more structured and institutional “cred”, such as citations, reviews, ratings,
and professional standards. Some social media services have had success with
simple systems for social reputation, such as “karma” in Slashdot, then Reddit,
but there is unmet need for much more — to shift from an attention economy
prioritizing empty engagement to one prioritizing trust.
Because trust varies by community, domain, and task — and
changes over time — reputation systems should be contextual and constantly
updating. They should be categorized to apply to people, communities, content,
and AI agents — including tracking of pseudonymous participants and human-AI
hybrids. To address varying perspectives on authority, they should flexibly
combine bottom-up judgments with context-relevant institutional credentials.
Reputation is a dynamically updating attribute used by the
other two pillars. Like all components, it depends on supporting technologies
for integrity, security, and privacy.
Tools for reputation/trust
Trust can be built from the bottom up, without reliance on
any one central authority, much the way Google’s PageRank
ranks web pages: by trusting those trusted by those we trust. Goldberg et al.
note use of PageRank as a trust signal, and use of reputation systems in
community governance. I generalize these into a pillar that can leverage
scalable, user-selectable, and portable systems, for bottom-up and transitive
trust — rather than rely only on ratings, “karma,” or centralized authority.
Personalized PageRank-inspired methods can compute the
transitivity of trust by degrees of separation (trust those trusted by those I
trust, n-levels deep), as I have elaborated.
This is distilled systematically from a global population, but applied with
respect to specific sources and domains. It can be protected
against gaming (albeit as a continuing cat and mouse game), and reduces the
need for some external “authority” whose legitimacy and contextual knowledge
are open to challenge.
Open interoperability: a flexible enablement foundation
Open
interoperability, both vertical and horizontal, is the foundation that
enables diverse elements of all three pillars and other elements to work in
concert — and be changed as needed. Protocols and APIs already support complex
business enterprise systems. They remain underdeveloped for individuals and
communities, but are beginning to emerge in social media and multi-agent AI.
Interoperability enables competition, portability, and
“exit” without losing data or connections — allowing old and new components to
be mixed, matched, substituted, and extended. That flexibility has costs,
including additional security
demands, but monolithic, proprietary systems are too rigid to accommodate
the diversity and ongoing evolution of human society.
Dominant platforms lack strong incentives to support the
pillars, or the interoperability that would enable open support for them.
Interop can weaken their control, since public-good support for the pillars may
not directly advance advertising revenue. That incentive problem is an
important obstacle for society to address — here again, a portfolio of innovative models
should be pursued.
Other technical, resourcing, and civic foundations
Beneath the pillars and interoperation sit three other kinds
of foundations: technical safeguards that every component needs, resourcing and
incentives, and the policy and civic support that markets alone can’t provide.
Widely accepted technical foundational needs include alignment, integrity,
security, privacy, and transparency (legibility). These are basic requirements
that underlie all three pillars.
Many current problems are recognized as related to
resourcing and incentives, but that derives primarily from an agency problem.
Again, a portfolio should be pursued: negotiating attention and data sharing
for advertising, potentially based on reverse metering; as well as alternative
resource sources, including both fee for service and public support. To be fair, pricing should
be value- and outcomes-based.
At the sociotechnical and civic level, market demand may
advance build-out of the pillars, open protocols, and AI agents, but policy,
regulation,
and standards could greatly facilitate securing agency, delegation,
interoperability, portability competition, and public-interest infrastructure.
US policy has badly neglected this, but the 2026 midterms are catalyzing a new
energy. Broad civic education is also needed so the public can understand
technological harms and demand remedies aimed at root causes rather than
symptoms — and demand that of their government representatives.
A loose, big-tent, multidisciplinary, whole-of-society
project portfolio
AI and social media are merging but being addressed
separately, and neither is being built to support the communities essential to
our humanity. Closing these disconnects will take a broad alliance working from
shared principles, and the Pro-Human AI Coalition seems well placed to start
that.
How we govern AI/SM will determine 1) whether it augments or
impairs collective intelligence, cooperation, and the workings of democracy
which already face growing challenges; and 2) whether humans can keep governing
and controlling increasingly powerful and potentially dangerous AI agents.
Because no one pillar can stand alone without serious weaknesses — and given
the very different challenges in social media and other uses of AI — shared
framing principles can provide common understanding, objectives, criteria, and
motivation for advancing a richly diverse interoperable and adaptable portfolio
within, across, and below the pillars.
Only through cooperation on shared goals can we develop a
coherent portfolio approach to marshal the tools and to guide the long-term
project of sociotechnical evolution. We need to re-engineer democracy for the
digital era and to govern AI — to overcome impending threats and enable
humanity to flourish. There are organizations supporting work in this
direction, but cooperation remains less integrated than needed across the
pillars and across AI and SM. A big-tent alliance could make that broader
alignment visible and actionable, and could refine and build on framing
principles like those I propose here. For example, it could explore how my
Three Pillars relate to the framework in Figure 3 of Weyl and colleagues’
Prosocial Media paper, and how these relate to stated objectives of the
coalition, as I discuss in the Supplement.
Project Liberty’s longstanding work on the social web gives
the new coalition a promising opportunity to integrate the social media
dimension into its agenda. A practical next step would be for this new
coalition, or others, to workshop shared framing principles and improve
information-sharing across a loosely federated portfolio. That could support
diverse experimentation and ongoing evolution of how the pillars and other
elements work together interoperably, without imposing a single program.
Conclusion and call to collective action
We are adding AI and social media into a society that
evolved over millennia to rely on communities and institutions for cooperation,
discourse, sense-making, and democratic governance. Yet development remains
piecemeal and concentrated in corporate systems whose incentives do not
reliably prioritize long-term public value — and more pro-human re-engineering
remains mostly reactive, with little overarching vision. Better alternatives
are emerging, but remain obscure, fragmented, and constrained by platform structures
and extreme concentrations of power. Current directions in AI seem to be
continuing the neglect of human communities and institutions. Humanity cannot
survive and flourish in a “post-social” world of people talking to computers —
we need a world of people talking to people, augmented by computers.
The proposed principles address five questions: 1) how
thought remains a social process; 2) how agency, social mediation, and
reputation reinforce one another when enabled by open interoperability; 3) how
users regain control of their attention and data, 4) how personal advocate AIs
can help individuals and communities ensure AIs that serve other parties
respect their agency and rights; and 5) above all, how every component must be
judged by who it serves. These principles should be simple and clear enough to
be understood and demanded by all.
The goal is to make our media tools intelligently social—supporting
democratic freedom and human flourishing through an open, evolving ecosystem.
Building it requires a broad alliance that can coordinate this sociotechnical
evolution without suppressing diversity and subsidiarity. The Pro-Human AI
Coalition could pursue this by convening its members to workshop these shared
principles — and drawing all of us into shaping this momentous transformation
of society.
Comments are invited -- via the Substack version of this article.
___
Acknowledgements: Thanks to my previous co-authors and
editors on these themes and to the many other colleagues for key insights and
valuable feedback that I have built on. And thanks to Audrey Hingle for
insightful editorial support. (AI was used for supplementary research and
analysis, and for suggesting condensations of text that I first drafted and
then carefully checked word by word.) This piece expresses my personal views,
not necessarily those of any organization I am affiliated with.



