Zuckerberg has rationalized that
Facebook should do nothing about lies, and Dorsey has Twitter copping to the
other extreme of an indiscriminate ad ban. But a readily actionable Goldilocks
solution has emerged in response – and there are reports
that Facebook is considering it.*
[This post focuses on stopgap solutions for controversial and urgent concerns leading in to the 2020 election. My prior post, Free Speech, Not Free Targeting! (Using Our Own Data to Manipulate Us), addresses the deeper abuses related to microtargeting and how everything in our feeds is filtered.]
[Update 5/29/20:]
Two bills to limit microtargeting of political ads have been introduced in Congress, one by Rep. Eshoo, and one by Rep. Cicilline. Both are along the lines of the proposals described here. (More at end.)
[Update 5/29/20:]
Two bills to limit microtargeting of political ads have been introduced in Congress, one by Rep. Eshoo, and one by Rep. Cicilline. Both are along the lines of the proposals described here. (More at end.)
The real problem
While dishonest political ads are a problem, that in itself is nothing new that we cannot deal with. What is new is microtargeting of dishonest ads, and that has created a crisis that puts the fairness of our elections in serous doubt. Numerous sophisticated observers – including the chair of the Federal Election Commission and the former head of security at Facebook -- have identified a far better stopgap solution than an outright ban on all political ads (or doing nothing).
While dishonest political ads are a problem, that in itself is nothing new that we cannot deal with. What is new is microtargeting of dishonest ads, and that has created a crisis that puts the fairness of our elections in serous doubt. Numerous sophisticated observers – including the chair of the Federal Election Commission and the former head of security at Facebook -- have identified a far better stopgap solution than an outright ban on all political ads (or doing nothing).
Since the real problem is
microtargeting, the “just right” quick solution is to limit microtargeting (at least until we have better ways to control it). Microtargeting provides the new and
insidious capability for a political campaign to precisely tailor its messaging
to microsegments of voters who are vulnerable to being manipulated in one way, and while sending many different,
conflicting messages to other microsegments who can be manipulated in other ways – by precision targeting down to designated sets of
individual voters (such as with multifacet categories or with Facebook Custom Audiences). The social media feedback cycle can further enlist those manipulated users to be used as conduits ("useful idiots") to amplify that harm throughout their social graphs (much like the familiar screech of audio feedback that is not properly damped). This new kind of message amplification
has been weaponized to incite extreme radicalization and even violent action.
We must be clear that there is a right of speech, but only limited rights to
amplification or targeting. We have always had political ads that lie. America
was founded on the principle that the best counter to lies is not censorship,
but truth. Policing lies is a very slippery slope, but when a lie is out in the
open, it can be exposed, debunked, and shamed. Sunlight has proven the
best disinfectant. With microtargeting there is no exposure to sunlight
and shame.
- This new microtargeted filtering service can direct user posts or paid advertising to those most vulnerable to being manipulated, without their informed permission or awareness.
- The social media feedback cycle can further enlist those manipulated users to be used as conduits ("useful idiots") to amplify that harm throughout their social graphs (much like the familiar screech of audio feedback that is not properly damped).
- These abuses are hidden from others and generally not auditable. That is compounds the harm of lies, since they can be targeted to manipulate factions surreptitiously.
Consensus for a stopgap solution
In the past week or so, limits on microtargeting have been suggested to take a range of forms, all of which seem workable and feasible:
In the past week or so, limits on microtargeting have been suggested to take a range of forms, all of which seem workable and feasible:
- Ellen Weintraub, chair of the Federal Election Commission (in the Washington Post), Don’t abolish political ads on social media. Stop microtargeting, suggests “A good rule of thumb could be for Internet advertisers to allow targeting no more specific than one political level below the election at which the ad is directed.
- Alex Stamos, former Facebook security chief, in an interview with Columbia Journalism Review, suggests “There are a lot of ways you can try to regulate this, but I think the simplest is a requirement that the "segment" somebody can hit has a floor. Maybe 10,000 people for a presidential election, 1,000 for a Congressional.”
- Siva Vaidhyanathan, in the NT Times, suggesting "here’s something Congress could do: restrict the targeting of political ads in any medium to the level of the electoral district of the race."
- In my prior post, I suggested “allow ads to only be run...in a way that is no more targeted than traditional media…such as to users within broad geographic areas, or to a single affinity category that is not more precise or personalized than traditional print or TV slotting options.
This seems to be an emerging consensus that this is the best we can expect to achieve in the short run, in time to
protect the 2020 election. This is something that Zuckerberg, Dorsey, and others (such as Google) could just decide to do -- or might be pressured to do. NBC News reported yesterday that Facebook is considering such an action.
We should all focus on avoiding foolish debate over naive framing of this problem as a dichotomy of "free speech" versus "censorship." The real problem is not the right of free speech, but the more nuanced issues of limited rights to be heard versus the right not to be targeted in ways that use our personal data against our interests.
The longer term
In the longer
term, dishonest political ads are only a part of this new problem of abuse of microtargeting,
which applies to speech of all kinds -- paid or not, political or commercial, or not. Especially notable is the fact
that much of what Cambridge Analytica did was to get ordinary people to spread
lies created by bots posing as ordinary people. To solve these problems, we need to change how the platforms not only how identity is known, but also how content is filtered into
our feeds. Filtering content into our feeds is a user service that should be designed to provide
the value that users, not advertisers seek.
There are huge opportunities for innovation here. My prior post explains that, shows how much we are missing because the platforms are now driven by advertiser needs for amplification of their voice, not user needs for filtering of all voices, and it points to how we might change that.
See my prior post for more, plus links to related posts.
---
*[Update 11/7:] WSJ reports Google is considering political ad targeting limits as well.
[Update 11/20:] Google has announced it will impose political ad targeting limits -- Zuck, your move.
[Update 11/22:] WSJ reports Facebook is considering similar political ad targeting limits.
The downside of targeting limits. Meanwhile, there are reports, notably in NYTimes, that highlight the downside of limiting targeting precision in this way. That is why it is prudent to view blanket limits not as a final cure, but a stopgap:
=========================
[Supplement 11/8:] These 11/5 updates from my prior post seem worth repeating here as added background:
In a 10/28 CJR interview by Mathew Ingram, Talking with former Facebook security chief Alex Stamos, Stamos offers this useful diagram to clarify key elements of Facebook and other social media that are often blurred together. He clarifies the hierarchy of amplification by advertising and recommendation engines (filtering of feeds) at the top, and free expression in various forms of private messaging at the bottom. This shows how the risks of abuse that need control are primarily related to paid targeting and to filtering. Stamos points out that "the type of abuse a lot of people are talking about, political disinformation, is absolutely tied to amplification" and that at the rights of unfettered free expression get stronger at the bottom, "the right of individuals to be exposed to information they have explicitly sought out."
Stamos argues that "Tech platforms should absolutely not fact-check candidates organic (unpaid) speech," but, in support of the kind of targeting limit suggested here, he says "I recommended, along with my partners here at Stanford, for there to be a legal floor on the advertising segment size for ads of a political nature."
Ben Thompson, in Tech and Liberty, supports Stamos' arguments and distinguishes rights of speech from "the right to be heard." He notes that "Targeting... both grants a right to be heard that is something distinct from a right to speech, as well as limits our shared understanding of what there is to debate."
---
See the Selected Items tab for more on this theme.
There are huge opportunities for innovation here. My prior post explains that, shows how much we are missing because the platforms are now driven by advertiser needs for amplification of their voice, not user needs for filtering of all voices, and it points to how we might change that.
See my prior post for more, plus links to related posts.
*[Update 11/7:] WSJ reports Google is considering political ad targeting limits as well.
[Update 11/20:] Google has announced it will impose political ad targeting limits -- Zuck, your move.
[Update 11/22:] WSJ reports Facebook is considering similar political ad targeting limits.
The downside of targeting limits. Meanwhile, there are reports, notably in NYTimes, that highlight the downside of limiting targeting precision in this way. That is why it is prudent to view blanket limits not as a final cure, but a stopgap:
- Political campaigns rightly point out how these limits harm legitimate campaign goals: “This change won’t curb disinformation...but it will hinder campaigns and (others) who are already working against the tide against bad actors to reach voters with facts.” “Broad targeting kills fund-raising efficiency”
- That argues that the real solution is to recognize that platforms do have the right and obligation to police ads of all kinds, including paid political ads, in order to enable an appropriate mix of targeting privileges to legitimate campaigns -- when placing non-abusive ads -- to those who choose to receive them.
- But since we are nowhere near a meaningful implementation of such a solution in time for major upcoming elections, we need a stopgap compromise now. That is why I originally advocated this targeting limit, while noting that it was only a stopgap.
[Update 5/29/20:]
Related to the update at the top, about the bills introduced in Congress, a nice statement quoted in the 5/26/20 Eshoo press release explains the problem in a nutshell:
Related to the update at the top, about the bills introduced in Congress, a nice statement quoted in the 5/26/20 Eshoo press release explains the problem in a nutshell:
It used to be true that a politician could tell different things to different voters, but journalists would check whether the politician in question was saying different things to different people and write about it if they found conflicting political promises. That is impossible now because the different messages are shown privately on social media, and a given journalist only has his or her own profile. In other words, it's impossible to have oversight. The status quo, in other words, is bad for democracy. This new bill would address this urgent problem. --Cathy O’Neil, author of Weapons of Math Destruction: How Big Data Increases Inequality and Threatens Democracy and CEO of ORCAA, an algorithmic auditing firm.
=========================
[Supplement 11/8:] These 11/5 updates from my prior post seem worth repeating here as added background:
(Alex Stamos from CJR) |
Stamos argues that "Tech platforms should absolutely not fact-check candidates organic (unpaid) speech," but, in support of the kind of targeting limit suggested here, he says "I recommended, along with my partners here at Stanford, for there to be a legal floor on the advertising segment size for ads of a political nature."
Ben Thompson, in Tech and Liberty, supports Stamos' arguments and distinguishes rights of speech from "the right to be heard." He notes that "Targeting... both grants a right to be heard that is something distinct from a right to speech, as well as limits our shared understanding of what there is to debate."
---
See the Selected Items tab for more on this theme.
I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful.
ReplyDelete360Digitmg machine learning course in hyderabad
Good Post! Thank you so much for sharing this pretty post, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, keep blogging.
DeleteApply for Canada Tourist Visa
I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work!
ReplyDeleteData-science course in chennai
I am looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work!
ReplyDelete360digitmg Machine learning course in hyderabad
We are offering Best AWS cloud practitioner course Online. Build your cloud skills with updated modules, instructor led live online courses & certifications. Enroll today.
ReplyDeletehttps://onlineidealab.com/aws-course/
Good day! I just want to give you a big thumbs up for the great information you have got right here on this post.Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
ReplyDeleteGoogle AdWords Course in Hyderabad
All the people involved can publish and let you know approximately whether they are coming or no longer and who all they may be planning to deliver alongside.wikipro
ReplyDeletethis is very informative article We are Indian visa passport service provider you can visit our website for know more us https://Indianvp.com/
ReplyDeleteThis post is very simple to read and appreciate without leaving any details out. Great work!
ReplyDeletedata science course noida
Whatsapp Number Call us Now! 01537587949
ReplyDeleteplease visit us: SEO Training
sex video: iphone repair in Novi
pone video usa: iphone repair in Novi
pone video usa: Social Bookmarking Sites List 2021
Nice article. I liked very much. All the information given by you are really helpful for my research. keep on posting your views.
ReplyDeletebest data science course in delhi
wm casino
ReplyDeleterespect55
เรียนภาษาอังกฤษ
poker
xxx
xxx
xxx ไทย
บาคาร่า
ReplyDeleteคาสิโนออนไลน์
พวงหรีด
ufabet
ufa
เว็บบอล
เว็บแทงบอล
ReplyDeleteโควิด
รับทำ seo
ufabet
ufa
kardinal stick
ReplyDeleteWatch movies online sa-movie.com, watch new movies, series Netflix HD 4K, ดูหนังออนไลน์ watch free movies on your mobile phone, Tablet, watch movies on the web.
ReplyDeleteSEE4K Watch movies, watch movies, free series, load without interruption, sharp images in HD FullHD 4k, all matters, ดูหนังใหม่ all tastes, see anywhere, anytime, on mobile phones, tablets, computers.
GangManga read manga, read manga, read manga online for free, fast loading, clear images in HD quality, all titles, อ่านการ์ตูน anywhere, anytime, on mobile, tablet, computer.
Watch live football live24th, watch football online, ผลบอลสด a link to watch live football, watch football for free.
SamudraBet Situs Judi Online Terbaik, Terpercaya dan Terbesar di Indonesia. Menyediakan permainan :
ReplyDeleteJudi bola terbaik
Judi slot online terpercaya
Poker online terbaru
Live casino online
Judi sabung ayam
VISTATOTO
ReplyDeleteVISTATOTO
VISTATOTO
VISTATOTO
VISTATOTO
VISTATOTO
Informative blog
ReplyDeletebest digital marketing institute in hyderabad
This is the best blog annualeventpost I ever see. Thanks for sharing information with us.
ReplyDeleteImpressive blog to be honest definitely this post will inspire many more upcoming aspirants. Eventually, this makes the participants to experience and innovate themselves through knowledge wise by visiting this kind of a blog. Once again excellent job keep inspiring with your cool stuff.
ReplyDeletedata science certification in bangalore
so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post.
ReplyDeletebusiness analytics course
Nice and very informative blog, glad to learn something through you.
ReplyDeletedata science course aurangabad
Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantastic lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your feed to stay informed of any updates.
ReplyDeletedata scientist course
I see some amazingly important and kept up to length of your strength searching for in your on the site
ReplyDeletedata scientist course
Clinical Research and Pharmacovigilance Course Certification Training Institute In Hyderabad
ReplyDeleteGratisol labs provides Clinical Research course and it is a leading Clinical Research training Institute providing Clinical Research Certification Coures . This Clinical Research Certification Course is covered with 4 Modules of Certification. Pharmacovigilance Certification Training, Clinical Data Management Certification Training,Regulatory Affairs Course and Medical Writing course and SAS Certification Training.
link text
link text
link text
link text
link text
link text
Today, I was just browsing along and came upon your blog. Just wanted to say good blog and this article helped me a lot, due to which I have found exactly I was looking. wiki
ReplyDeleteISC888 เกมยิงปลาออนไลน์ เกมสล็อต2021 หวยออนไลน์ แทงบอลออนไลน์ รูเล็ต โป๊กเกอร์ ไฮโล เสือมังกร ไพ่แบล็คแจ็ค พนันไก่ชน แข่งม้าออนไลน์ หวยฮานอย isc888 สมัครสมาชิก หวยออนไลน์ออกรางวัลทุกวัน เราก็มีบริการอีกเช่นกัน.
ReplyDeleteYou have written a lovely article; the importance of education is now spreading fire between people, especially in underdeveloped countries. Get an Online Class Software to simplify education.
ReplyDeletevirtual event platform No doubts this is one of the most exciting arenas for event technology developers. There is true value to be generated. Questions such as who is attending what demanded an answer. It looks like answers are piling up. falling jokes, happy first day of fall and birthday messages for sister
ReplyDeleteOur elite team is trained in anti-surveillance techniques and identifying unnatural behaviour.private security We’re skilled at situational awareness; that is, having a sharp eye and being constantly aware of everything that’s happening around you – the Principal.
ReplyDeleteTechnological advancements indeed have availed many devices and tools that bodyguard company
ReplyDeleteassist in security operations, but there are some qualities that security personnel must possess so they can use these devices and tools effectively. UK Close Protection Services is the industry leader when it comes to the provision of private security services.
I am glad to discover this page. I have to thank you for the time I spent on this especially great reading !! I really liked each part and also bookmarked you for new information on your site.
ReplyDeleteData Science Course in Delhi
Good Article, keep writing more,
ReplyDeleteDigital Marketing, Digital Marketing Online Training, Digital Marketing Training Programs, Women Entrepreneurship, Women Entrepreneurship Training Programs, Digital marketing online video course, Women Entrepreneurship Online Certification Course, Business coaching, Training for Business owners, Business coaching for women, young entrepreneurs training
https://www.eminentdigitalacademy.com
Digital Marketing Online Training
jamb registration for part time
ReplyDeleteVery nice blog, I really appreciate you for sharing this excellent and informative blog
Nice article. it is very valuable and helpful informative for me. Thanks for sharing these information with all of us. whatsapp mod
ReplyDeleteHigh-Quality and Genuinely-great blog. Thank you! For more information visit Pharmacovigilance Training Institute
ReplyDeleteGreat blog site .Thank you so much for sharing this post with us .dehumidifier price in Bangladesh
ReplyDeleteYour post was really good. I like it very much. I like your blog site a lot. So thank you so much for sharing this important topic with us. Hope to share more good posts with us in future. diploma in engineering
ReplyDeleteReally it is a very interesting blog site. And your posts are very beautiful, I am very impressed for your post. And thank you so much for sharing this post web development company in Bangladesh
ReplyDeleteMeteor88 merupakan situs judi online terpercaya yang menyediakan permainan judi online uang asli terlengkap di Indonesia. Meteor88 Menyediakan permainan Judi Online paling lengkap diantaranya : Sportsbook, Slot Online, Live Casino, Poker Online, Judi Tangkas, Tembak Ikan, Sabung Ayam dan Togel Online. Semuanya bisa di mainkan hanya dengan 1 User ID. Selain menyediakan permainan judi online yang begitu lengkap, meteor88 juga menyediakan Bonus yang sangat menarik untuk para membernya, diantaranya : Bonus New Member 100%, Bonus Deposit Harian 10%, Bonus Cash Back 15%, Bonus Rollingan 1% dan Bonus Refferal sebesar 20%.
ReplyDeleteUntuk Informasi lebih lanjut silahkan kunjungi link di bawah ini :
Judi bola online resmi
Judi slot online terpercaya
Judi live casino terbaik
Judi poker online terbaik
Judi tembak ikan terbaru
Judi sabung ayam online
It is extremely nice to see the greatest details presented in an easy and understanding manner.
ReplyDeletefull stack web development course in malaysia
As the Internet develops further in the future, I think we need to collect materials that people might be interested in. Among the data to be collected, your 메가슬롯 will also be included.
ReplyDeleteThis post is easy to peruse and acknowledge without forgetting about any subtleties. Extraordinary work!
ReplyDelete360DigiTMG, the top-rated organisation among the most prestigious industries around the world, is an educational destination for those looking to pursue their dreams around the globe. The company is changing careers of many people through constant improvement, 360DigiTMG provides an outstanding learning experience and distinguishes itself from the pack. 360DigiTMG is a prominent global presence by offering world-class training. Its main office is in India and subsidiaries across Malaysia, USA, East Asia, Australia, Uk, Netherlands, and the Middle East.
ReplyDeleteYour post was really pretty. I like it a lot. Your blog site is very informative and helpful. The term Internet Service Provider (ISP) refers to a company that provides Internet access to both personal and business customers. ISPs make it possible for their clients to surf the web, shop online runs a business, and connect with family and friends - in exchange for everything. ISPs can also provide other services including email services, domain registration, web hosting, and browser packages. Our blog site is related to Internet Service Provider (ISP). I believe that my blog site is more helpful than all other blog sites. We provide the best service to everyone. best isp in Dhaka
ReplyDeleteSlope is the most exciting speed game. At first glance, the game may seem simple, but you should try to play it at least once. You will not notice how you spend several hours enthusiastically playing it. The game developers have thought through every detail so that you not only play the game but also develop your reaction. The simple design of the Slope unblocked games will not overload your visual channel, so you can play it for several hours and not feel exhausted. This game is suitable for both young children and adults - it is universal and will interest any player.
ReplyDeleteInformative article. Thanks for sharing with us.keep it up.
ReplyDeletedata science courses in aurangabad
We are a top rated ACCG315 Online service here with experts specializing in a wide range of disciplines ensuring you get the assignments that score maximum grades.
ReplyDeleteI would like to say that this blog really convinced me to do it and thanks for informative post and bookmarked to check out new things of your post…
ReplyDeleteData Science Institute in Noida
Good day! I just want to give you a big thumbs up for the great information you have got right here on this post.Thanks for sharing your knowledge.
ReplyDeleteReal Estate Lawyer in Brampton
ANZSLOT Situs slot pay4D terpercaya bonus 100% didepan deposit pulsa 24 jam tanpa potongan paling gacor se Indonesia.
ReplyDeleteKhusus untuk permainan slot, live casino dan poker online, kami memberikan turn over yang sampai dengan 1%. Semakin lama Anda bermain, semakin banyak turn over yang akan Anda dapatkan. Ini berarti, kalah juga dibayar. Slot deposit pulsa
ReplyDeletedecent post I gain new knowledge from various blogs every day. It's always interesting to read other authors' writing and conduct some research on their websites. I'll use every bit of information, whether you agree with me or not, on my main website. Naturally, I'll provide you the web address for my blog. Thank you for sharing.
ReplyDeleteDaftar Slot Gacor Hari Ini
I’m looking forward to reading more informative articles like this. It contains a wide spectrum of details and information for students who want to enrol in a proper course curriculum and are looking for good options. Best Data Science Institute In Chennai With Placement
ReplyDelete