Showing posts with label bricks and clicks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bricks and clicks. Show all posts

Monday, June 19, 2017

Bricks and Clicks -- Showrooming, Riggio, and Bezos

Last week brought two notable news items about Amazon and the future or retail. Most noted was the deal to buy Whole Foods, which would greatly accelerate Amazon's move to the center of the still rudimentary combination of bricks and clicks. Drawing some limited attention was the issuance of an Amazon patent (filed in May, 2012) on smart ways to turn showrooming to a store's advantage.

This was especially relevant to me for several reasons:
  • I have been dabbling in bricks and clicks since at least twenty years ago, when I tried to pitch Steve Riggio of Barnes & Noble, on a bricks and clicks strategy to counter Amazon (to no avail).
  • It was gratifying to see that the Amazon patent cited seventeen of my patents or applications as prior art. 
  • My 2013 post, The Joy of Showrooming:  From Profit Drain to Profit Center, outlined promising ideas much along the lines of aspects of Amazon's patent. My ideas were for collaboration of the showroom owner and the Web competitor, to optimize the best value exchange, based on showrooming referral fees that compensate the showroom owner for the showroom service provided.
The IoBC (Internet of Bricks and Clicks)

The Internet of Things has gotten much press about how it connects not just people and businesses, but literally everyThing. Few grasp even the early impacts of this sea change, and even the technically sophisticated can only dimly grasp where it will take us.

Bricks and clicks is just an aspect of that. It is much like the famous New Yorker's View of the World magazine cover by Steinberg.
  • Traditional retail businesses view online from their store-centered perspective, adding online services to counter and co-opt the enemy attack.
  • Online businesses view stores from the online-centered perspective, dabbling in stores and depots to expand their beachhead.
  • Only a few, like Bezos, see the big picture of an agnostic, flexible blend of resources and capabilities that most effectively provide what we want, when and how we want it.
To see the larger view we must climb above our attachments to stores and warehouses, or Web sites and apps. We must consider the objectives of the customers and how best to give them whatever they want, with whatever resources can be applied, as costs permit. How we orchestrate those resources to meet those objectives will change rapidly, as our systems and their integration improves. Only the most far-sighted and nimble will see and go more than a few steps down this path.

The WSJ op-ed on the merger and article on patent give some hint of the kind of changes we can look forward to (and I expand on that below). Fasten your seat belts, it's going to be a bumpy ride.

The User-Centered view

This blog, User-Centered Media, is focused on my dominant perspective on technology -- as a tool to improve our lives. While many of the most creative people in technology work for businesses that sell technology products (resources) for others to use, for most of my career I worked for companies that wanted to use technology. Vendors want to make what they know and sell what they make. Users want to find whatever resources they need and put them together to help their people do things -- whether the resources are people, computers, Web sites, networks, devices, stores, warehouses, or transport.

So far bricks and clicks have been developing from the two poles, but that has not taken us very far. But it seems we may be at an inflection point:
  • The two articles I cited above give a hint of what we will begin to see form in the middle. Amazon has been in the lead and just took a big step forward. The WSJ op-ed observes: "Mr. Bezos’s ambition is...oriented toward accelerating consumer gratification however possible."
  • Additional perspectives on Bezos' user-centered innovation style were in the Times a few days ago. 
  • In a NY Times Upshot article today quoting Erik Brynjolfsson, "The bigger and more profound way that technology affects jobs is by completely reinventing the business model...Amazon didn’t go put a robot into the bookstores and help you check out books faster. It completely reinvented bookstores."
  • More detail on the guts of integration is reviewed in another Times article today. 
  • Still another Times article today looks at the symmetry of the Amazon-Whole Foods deal and the Walmart-Bonobos deal. 
  • And still another looks at the similar synergies of the Target investment in Casper. 
Bezos is well on the way to this broad reinvention of retail, but, as suggested in a recent (May!) article on how VR/AR might factor into this by my old friend Gary Arlen (and our online comments back and forth), we are still far from game over.

With that, I indulge in some comments on my own dabblings in this space.

The Barnes & Noble that might have been

Just over twenty years ago I was invited to a B&N focus group when Amazon was just nipping at their heels and they had just built their Web site. Based on my reactions to what I saw, I wrote to Riggio, then COO, on May 8, 1997:
B&N on the Web presents an exciting opportunity to leverage your store-based business with your online business at three levels:
  • In-store uses of the Web as a kiosk to provide a new richness in self-service (using Firefly, book reviews, and other aids). 
  • Hybrid uses of remote Web access as a prelude to a store visit (such as to pre-select a book, find the nearest store that has it, and put it on hold for pickup)
  • Remote uses that you are off to a good start on (featuring collaborative filtering and other recommender and community-building tools)
I can help not only with the new media side of this, but also with the back-end integration. 
Just first steps -- but all in software, with no need for any changes at all to their physical logistics. Where might B&N be now if Riggio responded to my letter?

The Joy of Showrooming

In May 2013 (May seems a good month for this), I did a post, The Joy of Showrooming: From Profit Drain to Profit Center. It addresses new methods much the same as those in the Amazon patent (which was filed a year earlier than my post, so I am glad I chose not to apply for a patent!). After some comments on the emerging concerns about showrooming and price-checking apps, I said:
What I suggest is to take this threat, and view it as an opportunity:
  • What if showrooming activity could be tracked, and e-tailers convinced to pay a "showroom fee" to the provider of a showrooming service, if the sale came from that showroom? 
  • What if the retailer could filter Internet traffic from their store, and trace which URLs are for competitors, track purchase transactions that emanate from the store, and pass through only those that go to retailers that agree to pay the fee? 
There are a number of ways this can be done, and that can lead to a new retail ecology that benefits all.
It is not clear where Amazon wants to go with this, and whether they want to build an ecosystem with other strong players. But as Arlen and I agree, these are still early days -- others may seize the opportunity to build a showrooming referral ecosystem (but now should consider to what extent the Amazon patent might impede them).

(I have not checked which of my patents were cited by Amazon, but in general my inventions relate to a user-centered view of networked resources, and of the IoT. And for those who might care about IP issues, all of my patents have been sold, and I am not actively involved in getting more.)

[Update 6/20: A Forrester blog post made an interesting observation: "Amazon knows that to win at brick and mortar, retail theater is paramount. Whole Foods locations are destinations where the idea of “Retail Theater” still thrives." Showrooming is theater.]

The Future of Retail

In 2014 I co-led the very stimulating MIT Enterprise Forum of NYC: Think Tank Session III: The Future of Retail: Reinventing how people get stuff (one of a series on The Future of X). This Think Tank brought together thirteen "lead participants" with diverse expertise in the field for an open brainstorming with about sixty other technology entrepreneur "participants." While aspects of the video are now dated, those who care to look are likely to find many examples of forward thinking that are still timely.

And now for something not completely different

While most of my work on my current main project, FairPay, is not specifically oriented to bricks, it does bring the same kind of user-centered, customer-first thinking to retail. Much of the focus is on the digital realm, but it suggests some new directions that relate to the physical realm as well. For more ideas on those aspects of the future of retail, check out my other blog, The FairPay Zone.

---
[Update 3/31/18: Sloan Management Review published an excellent article on this theme: The Store Is Dead — Long Live the Store.]



Thursday, May 23, 2013

The Joy of Showrooming: From Profit Drain to Profit Center

Showrooming has become a major scourge of bricks-and-mortar retail, but maybe it is the way to a new golden age.  I suggest that showrooming can become a major source of profit, and can enable retail businesses to fully exploit the value of showrooms in our experience economy.

Brick-and-mortar stores like Best Buy and Walmart are struggling as e-tailers like Amazon and many others are stealing their lunch with more efficient channels and lower prices.  Adding insult to injury, they are losing increasing portions of business to the practice of "showrooming," where a customer comes into a store to view merchandise, checks for better prices online, and then buys from Amazon or others.  Services like Amazon's Price Check app have become popular to facilitate just that.  It is reported that 60% of Best Buy customers use thier smartphones to comparison shop.

Faced with this serious challenge, the reaction of retailers has been to try to impede it.  The main response has been to increasingly customize products so that they cannot be found and compared online, having manufacturers create SKUs that exist only for them (whether name brand or private label).  Oher counters are more dynamic pricing and price-match offers.

What I suggest is to take this threat, and view it as an opportunity:
  • What if showrooming activity could be tracked, and e-tailers convinced to pay a "showroom fee" to the provider of a showrooming service, if the sale came from that showroom? 
  • What if the retailer could filter Internet traffic from their store, and trace which URLs are for competitors, track purchase transactions that emanate from the store, and pass through only those that go to retailers that agree to pay the fee? 
There are a number of ways this can be done, and that can lead to a new retail ecology that benefits all.

Showrooming has great economic value.  It enabled customers to see, feel, and try products.  That has been a serious limitation of e-commerce, and has been exploited by those who recognize the value of show, like Apple.  Now Samsung is working with Best Buy to do that as well.  But this has been on a closed basis, for single brands.

How could showrooming fees be obtained? 
  • One method that seems promising is for retailers to place microcells in their stores to carry cellular traffic, and work with the carriers to track and monitor the traffic, and seek agreements with electronic competitors to pay a fee in exchange for the showrooming service.  This might be done through independent parties that ensure privacy, aid in the negotiations, and address any legal issues that may be involved (such as the wireless carriers, or specialized third parties).  Sellers that refuse to pay such fees might be blocked. (This can be done using some combination of blacklists and whitelists.  A microcell alone might not eliminate all uncontrolled mobile access, but, if necessary stores might use shielding to prevent that.)  While blocking traffic may have legal ramifications, if it is done for such valid economic reasons, and in a way that ensures passage of non-commercial messaging, waivers might be sought as necessary.  Mobile carriers might find this a desirable way to obtain new revenues.
  • Offering free WiFi service would provide a similar way to filter and track such traffic--and to introduce related in-store messaging services as well.  Even without any limits to cellular access, this might provide a value-added service channel, and do the job well enough, in simpler manner.
  • Offering comparative shopping tools that are showroom-fee-compliant and given favored treatment might be a way to get get customers to facilitate such a process without need to filter all mobile traffic.
  • This could also be facilitated via loaner mobile devices or in-store kiosks.
  • An even higher touch service might be achieved with personal shopper programs.  The personal shopper might facilitate the online sale with partners that cooperate. 
If we open our eyes to the positive side of showrooming, this can lead to a virtuous value cycle for all.

On the e-tailer side, working with showroomers can provide numerous valuable benefits that are worth a reasonable fee:
  • Customers can experience the items, know exactly what they are getting, and order with less likelihood of returns, reducing costs to the electronic retailer.
  • Cooperating retailers can get featured access and be more likely to be found.
  • Correct identification of products can be facilitated (reducing return costs and increasing satisfaction).
On the retail showroom side, working with electronic retailers in return for showrooming fees can provide a whole new range of possibilities for profit:
  • Instead of spending money creating inefficiencies just to prevent showrooming, those costs can be eliminated.
  • Fees can be negotiated based on the level of showrooming services offered, ranging from a boxed item on a shelf, to play with the item, to guided demonstratins and advice by sales staff and full personal shopper services.
  • With greater probability of compensation from both direct sales and showroomed sales, physical retailers can spend more to make their showrooms into rich and valuable customer experiences.
  • Showrooms might even emerge as free-standing businesses--sort of an experiential shopping Disneyland--with all sales and fulfilment done by an open market of electronic retailers.
  • By passing some sales to electronic counterparties, the physical retailer finds real offsetting savings by eliminating need for much of their inventory and eliminating returns.  By cutting these costs, showrooming fees need not be equal to the full in-house sales margin.
This creates opportunities for more complex cooperation:
  • Physical retailers can serve as pickup and return centers for electronic retailers, whether for products they do carry or for those they don't. Amazon, ThankYou Rewards, and others already are seeking just such physical services in non-competing venues, but much richer possibilities might be enabled in a more open ecosystem. (A complementary step in this direction is the ShopRunner service.)
  • The various elements, costs, and benefits of the retail supply chain and service ecology can be deconstructed, and broken into elements that can be costed and charged for individually, and handled by whatever party is most capable of doing it in a way the is efficient and serves all. This can cover the range from marketing, selection guidance, demos, sales transactions, fulfillment, service and support.  Best Buy might even swap inventory for pickups of Amazon sales, with bulk replenishment by Amazon.  It might also facilitate blurring boundaries between sales and subscription services.
There is great economic value to a rich showroom experience.  We see that in many department and specialty stores, in Apple stores, and in The Samsumg Experience stores.  People like to kick the tires, see the alternatives in real space, talk to sales people face to face, and have a fun family or social experience.  What is the sense of a business ecology that pushes bricks-and-mortar retail toward commoditization and increasing friction?  Why not find a way for complementary players to work together?

---
Ideas in bottles.  This is one of what may become a series, publishing some of my inventions without any effort to seek a patent.  Just putting the idea in a bottle, throwing it into the Internet sea, and seeing where it floats, for whoever wants to apply it.  Of course this post just skims the surface, and patent opportunities remain in the details (such as filtering and payment/settlement systems) for those with the inclination to develop them (and at some point I might decide to jump in myself).  Creating such an ecosystem will not be easy, but I think there is very great potential here.  I would be happy to collaborate with those who might pursue this.

---
[Update 6/16/17: The press made much of an Amazon patent on much the same ideas, including ideas for doing counteroffers, that was issued this week (and was filed a year prior to this post). (I was pleased to see that the Amazon patent cited 17 of my earlier patents/applications as prior art, and also happy that I chose not to file for a patent on these particular ideas!) For those interested in applying the ideas outlined here, the newly issued Amazon patent may add a complication.]